FY2025 SEC EDGAR DEF 14A #18 of 56 in industry

American Financial Group Inc CEO pay ratio

The CEO earned $11.1M in FY2025 against median worker pay of $110,944 · Insurance Carriers.

Insurance Carriers peers All rankings
State
OH
Filing date
2026-04-03
Industry
Insurance Carriers
Industry rank
#18/56

Data updated August 2026

Subscribe to American Financial Group Inc CEO pay filing updates (RSS)

CEO-to-worker pay ratio
100:1
Moderate (Scale: 0–1000:1)
CEO pay
$11.1M
Median worker
$110,944

Answer first

American Financial Group Inc's FY2025 CEO total of $11.1M ranks #462 of 1,423 complete filings; its 100:1 pay ratio ranks #634. Dollar rank is not ratio rank.

According to the same FY2025 complete-filing cohort used on the rankings boards (CEO total, median worker, and ratio all present). Median worker pay is $110,944. Industry placement uses the FY2025 SIC-63 peer cohort (# 18 of 56, 70th percentile - above the industry median pay ratio). Figures come from Section 953(b) Dodd-Frank DEF 14A disclosures - not estimates. View all Insurance Carriers companies.

Dollar rank
#462
$11.1M of 1,423 FY2025
Ratio rank
#634
100:1 of 1,423
Industry pct
70th
above the industry median pay ratio

How American Financial Group Inc ranks nationally

American Financial Group Inc CEO pay vs. every FY2025 complete filing

Total CEO compensation, the full national distribution, this company marked

$11,094,400 Top 32% higher than 68% of 1,423 companies

$0–$2,500,000: 304 companies (21%). Below this entry. $2,500,000–$5,000,000: 182 companies (13%). Below this entry. $5,000,000–$7,500,000: 208 companies (15%). Below this entry. $7,500,000–$10,000,000: 192 companies (13%). Below this entry. $10,000,000–$12,500,000: 139 companies (10%). This entry sits in this band. $12,500,000–$15,000,000: 91 companies (6%). Above this entry. $15,000,000–$17,500,000: 88 companies (6%). Above this entry. $17,500,000–$20,000,000: 54 companies (4%). Above this entry. $20,000,000–$22,500,000: 24 companies (2%). Above this entry. $22,500,000–$25,000,000: 34 companies (2%). Above this entry. $25,000,000–$27,500,000: 24 companies (2%). Above this entry. $27,500,000–$30,000,000: 16 companies (1%). Above this entry. $30,000,000–$32,500,000: 10 companies (1%). Above this entry. $32,500,000–$35,000,000: 7 companies (0%). Above this entry. $35,000,000–$37,500,000: 9 companies (1%). Above this entry. $37,500,000–$40,000,000: 6 companies (0%). Above this entry. $40,000,000–$42,500,000: 1 companies (0%). Above this entry. $42,500,000–$45,000,000: 1 companies (0%). Above this entry. $45,000,000–$47,500,000: 6 companies (0%). Above this entry. $47,500,000–$50,000,000: 27 companies (2%). Above this entry. This company $0 $50M+ every complete-filing company, bucketed by value

Each bar is a $2500K-wide band; taller bars hold more companies. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.

Source SEC DEF 14A Section 953(b) disclosures, PlainCEOPay extract · FY2025

American Financial Group Inc vs. Insurance Carriers peers

CEO total pay ($11.1M) against pay ratio (100:1) for American Financial Group Inc (marked) and its 3 closest same-industry peers, against the Insurance Carriers industry median on both axes.

Pay + gap both highContained pay, wide gapHigh pay, contained gapBelow peer norms on both5359457.56861466.383634759865483.811367492.567.4:176.2:185:193.8:1102.6:1CEO total payPay ratio (CEO : median worker)American Financial Group Inc, CEO total pay: 11094400 · Pay ratio (CEO : median worker): 100:1American Financial Group IncFirst American Financial Corp, CEO total pay: 8308866 · Pay ratio (CEO : median worker): 101:1First American Financial CorpOld Republic International Corp, CEO total pay: 8212204 · Pay ratio (CEO : median worker): 98:1Old Republic International CorpPrimerica, Inc., CEO total pay: 5632550 · Pay ratio (CEO : median worker): 95:1Primerica, Inc.
American Financial Group Inc vs. Insurance Carriers peers, plotted against the industry's $8.3M median CEO total and 69:1 median pay ratio.

Ratio bands among Insurance Carriers peers

Exclusive CEO-to-median-worker bands across 51 complete latest-FY filings in SIC 63. Segments sum to the peer set, not this company's compensation pillar.

CEO Compensation Breakdown, FY2025

A component-level pay breakdown is not reported in American Financial Group Inc's structured SEC pay-ratio disclosure. See our methodology →

Filing-year trail · American Financial Group Inc

Complete DEF 14A pay-ratio filings for this CIK across FY2021–2025. Year-over-year deltas compare adjacent filing years only; incomplete dollar rows are omitted (same completeness gate as the hero figures).

Latest ratio
100:1
FY2025
vs prior FY
-17:1
from FY2024 117:1
CEO $ YoY
-4.4%
$11.1M latest
Filings shown
4
FY2021–2025
American Financial Group Inc CEO total compensation, median worker pay, and pay ratio by fiscal year from SEC EDGAR DEF 14A.
FY CEO pay Δ pay Median worker Pay ratio Δ ratio
2021 $12.5M - $71,738 174:1 -
2023 $10.1M -19% $93,066 108:1 -66:1
2024 $11.6M +15% $99,192 117:1 +9:1
2025 $11.1M -4.4% $110,944 100:1 -17:1

Source: SEC EDGAR DEF 14A pay-ratio disclosures for CIK 1042046, FY2021–2025. Adjacent-year deltas only.

Industry Comparison - Insurance Carriers

This Company's Ratio
100:1
Industry Median Ratio
69:1
Industry Median CEO Pay
$8.3M
This CEO's Pay
$11.1M
Companies in Industry
56
vs. Industry Median
Above
#18 of 56 by pay ratio in this industry View all companies in Insurance Carriers →

American Financial Group Inc: MID · HEAVY pay ratio

American Financial Group Inc's FY2025 ratio 100:1 ranks #18 of 56 Insurance Carriers filers (70th percentile). the CEO earned 100× the median employee ($110,944) in FY2025.

Median employee $110,944 (HIGH-MED); MID · HEAVY stamps put about 100 median-wage years per CEO year.

CEO Total Pay

$11.1M

FY2025 Summary Compensation, above median

Pay Ratio

100:1

Near industry median

American Financial Group Inc in the higher Insurance Carriers third

American Financial Group Inc's FY2025 ratio 100:1 ranks #18 of 56 Insurance Carriers filers (70th percentile). The structured pay-ratio disclosure reports the total without line-item components. Insurance Carriers (SIC 63) median ratio is 69:1 across 56 FY2025 filers; American Financial Group Inc's $11.1M CEO total is above the $8.3M industry median CEO pay.

Dollar rank #462 and ratio rank #634 split - treat 100:1 as a disclosure, not a fairness score. Open Insurance Carriers peers.

Key Data, FY2025

Total Compensation
$11.1M
Median Employee Pay
$110,944
Pay Ratio
100:1
Filing Date
2026-04-03

Company Info

CIK
1042046
Industry
Insurance Carriers
SIC Code
6331
State
OH
View SEC filings →
SEC EDGAR DEF 14A for CIK 1042046, FY2025. Informational only, not investment advice. Verify on EDGAR.

Read our methodology - how this data is sourced, computed, and verified. American Financial Group Inc's FY2025 ratio 100:1 ranks #18 of 56 Insurance Carriers filers (70th percentile).

Read with American Financial Group Inc

ABS(ceo_total_comp) peers first, then a SIC pole and a stamp-branched guide - not a fixed Related strip. This page stamps MID · HEAVY · HIGH-MED.

Group 1 Automotive Inc · HEAVY

ABS(ceo_total_comp) peer at $11.1M (Δ $11K heavier vs American Financial Group Inc); STEEP · PAR-MED vs this page's MID · HEAVY · HIGH-MED.
Fifth Third Bancorp · HEAVY

ABS(ceo_total_comp) peer at $11.1M (Δ $42K lighter vs American Financial Group Inc); MID · HIGH-MED vs this page's MID · HEAVY · HIGH-MED.
C. H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc. · HEAVY

ABS(ceo_total_comp) peer at $11.0M (Δ $48K lighter vs American Financial Group Inc); STEEP · PAR-MED vs this page's MID · HEAVY · HIGH-MED.
Polaris Inc. · HEAVY

ABS(ceo_total_comp) peer at $11.1M (Δ $50K heavier vs American Financial Group Inc); STEEP · LOW-MED vs this page's MID · HEAVY · HIGH-MED.
Essent Group Ltd. (SIC 63 pole)

Essent Group Ltd. stamps MID · UNFILED nearest in-SIC by ABS(pay_ratio) to American Financial Group Inc's MID filing.
National dual ranks · #462/#634

American Financial Group Inc's FY2025 package sits #462 by CEO dollars and #634 by ratio under HEAVY · MID.
Comp structure · HEAVY

American Financial Group Inc's HEAVY CEO total is equity-sensitive - read what grant-date fair value does and does not mean.
Data sourced from SEC EDGAR DEF 14A for American Financial Group Inc (CIK 1042046), FY2025. See our methodology. Aggregated by PlainCEOPay as of August 2026.

Data currency: Executive compensation from SEC EDGAR DEF 14A proxy statements through fiscal year 2025, compiled and last refreshed August 2026. See our methodology for source dates and refresh cadence. Spot a figure that looks wrong? Report a correction.